The Pros and Cons of Various Centrifugal Pump Casing Types

By Allan Budris

SGB Product Page

Casing type can have a large impact on pump reliability (the mean time between repairs) and, to a lesser extent, pump efficiency when pump flow rates are above or below the best efficiency point (BEP). Although the objective of many pump applications may be to operate the pump at its BEP, this is often not achieved due to:

• The current pump system friction head not being accurately identified when the pump is purchased
• Excessive safety factors added to the pump selection to plan for future pump wear
• Wear of the pump over time
• Changes and/or increases in the system friction head over time
• Changes in the system static and/or friction head during normal operation

The three basic casing types primarily used for centrifugal pumps are the single volute, double volute and vaned diffuser. Of these, the most common - at least for low- to medium-flow, single-stage pumps - is the single volute, with double volutes used more for larger, single-stage pumps handling liquids without solids, and vaned diffusers primarily applied to multistage pumps.

Each of these casing types has its advantages and disadvantages regarding bearing and shaft seal life, pump efficiency and pump cost. Although pump users do not always have a choice of the casing type, there are applications where at least some vendors may provide the pump user with this decision. It is, therefore, advantageous for pump users to be knowledgeable regarding the impact of these potential casing selections.

Single Volute Casing

Single volute pumps have been in existence for several years. With the exception of vertical pumps of the turbine type, the majority of single-stage pumps built in the United States are of the single volute type. The main advantage of single volute casing is its simplicity: it is less difficult to cast, and therefore less expensive to produce given the open areas surrounding the impeller periphery. At flow rates near the pump BEP, single volute casings are more efficient than double volute casings. Further, the inherent greater throat areas can also handle larger solids, as found in wastewater.

The volute scroll is designed for constant velocity near the best efficiency flow rate, which yields a uniform static pressure around the periphery of the impeller but only at the BEP (see Fig. 1). This pressure equilibrium is, however, destroyed when the pump is operating at flow rates below (see Fig. 2) or above the BEP. Figure 2 shows the pressure distribution around the impeller in a single volute at zero flow rate, where A = total reaction, B = reaction on side shrouds, C = reaction on impeller periphery, and D = non-uniform fluid momentum. This off-BEP, non-uniform pressure distribution around the impeller results in increased net radial loads on the rotor (see Fig. 3). Likewise, this increased load deflects the pump shaft and can result in excessive deterioration at the wearing rings, seals or bearings. In extreme cases, shaft breakage due to fatigue can result.

The primary load on the pump bearings typically derives from this pressure imbalance around the impeller (at least in a single volute), especially at off-design flow conditions. The impact of this unbalanced pressure force on the bearing L10 fatigue life is further amplified by the fact that the antifriction (ball or roller) bearing life is a function of the cube of the radial load. This means that the bearing life quickly diminishes away from the BEP. The statistical (L10) ball bearing life ratings are based on metal fatigue failure, with 90 percent of the bearings surviving for the rated time period.

The only way to improve single volute pump bearing life is to operate the pumps as close to the pump BEP as practical for the application, possibly by adding a bypass line from the discharge header to the suction pipe. This can, however, also reduce the overall pump efficiency for the resulting net flow rate.

More Pump Tips

Back to Basics: Pump Factory Performance Tests

Selecting the Optimum Pump Control Valve to Save Substantial Wasted Energy Dollars

Back to Basics: How to Improve Vertical Turbine Pump Reliability through Optimum Bearing Selection

Pump Protection: The Pros and Cons of Various Centrifugal Pump Casing Types

Considerations for Designing Piping Adjacent to a Centrifugal Pump

Bearing Burdens: Reducing Lubrication Contaminants to Improve Bearing Life, Lifecycle Costs

Power Precautions: Analyzing Pump Startup and Shutdown Best Practices

Double Volute Casing

Double volute casings were introduced to eliminate the radial thrust problems inherent in the single volute design. Test measurements do, however, indicate that while the radial forces in a double volute are greatly reduced, they are not completely eliminated (as shown in Figure 3).

In a double volute casing, the flow is divided into two equal streams with two cut-waters set 180 degrees apart. The total throat area of the two volutes is identical to that which would be used on a comparable single volute design. As such, a double volute casing design is actually a single volute with a splitter vane extending 180 degrees from what would be the single volute throat welling into the diffuser section, creating two equal scrolls, each with constant velocity at the pump BEP. The two volute sections still generate non-uniform pressures around the impeller at off-BEP flow rates but tend to cancel each other out to a large extent, as shown by the resulting lower radial loads in Figure 3. This is the main reason for using a double volute casing.

Are you interested in learning more about Pump Volute Casing? Contact us today to secure an expert consultation!

The hydraulic performance of double volute pumps is nearly as good as that of single volute pumps. Tests indicate that a double volute pump will be approximately one to one-and-a-half points less efficient at the BEP but will be approximately two points more efficient on either side of the BEP than with a comparable single volute pump. This means that a double volute casing will produce a slightly higher efficiency over the full range of the head-capacity curve than a single volute.

Double volutes are most common with larger-axial, split-case, double-suction impeller pumps, which also have lower-axial impeller loads. Double volute casings should not be used in smaller, low-flow pumps (below about 400 gpm). Since larger pumps are better candidates for double volutes, they should normally be selected for such service when available and if the application permits. The splitter vane in a double volute can cause blockage problems when handling solids, such as in wastewater applications, which would preclude their use in these applications.

Vaned Diffuser Casing

Vaned diffuser casings are typically used for vertical turbine and multistage, high-head pumps for maximum pump reliability and where high efficiency is of major importance. High efficiency is not the only advantage for a vaned diffuser pump. In the vaned type, the impeller discharges into a uniform ring of nozzles, and consequently the radial loading on the impeller is fully balanced (meaning zero radial load over the full flow range).

The runner of the vaned diffuser pump is surrounded by gradually-expanding passages formed by stationary guide vanes (see Fig. 4). In this type of casing, the velocity head of the liquid leaving the impeller is converted more completely into pressure than in the volute type, potentially making its efficiency slightly higher. However, the added cost and more complicated construction of the vaned diffuser pump, compared with a single volute, are generally not considered justifiable for the efficiency advantage alone, except in vertical-turbine and large, high-pressure pumps.

Obviously, the pump casing is the outer shell of the pump, which can be understood as the container of the pump. It is used to accommodate the key components of the pump (impeller, pump shaft, sealing device, etc.), to fix the position of the pump components, and to maintain stability.

As a hard outer shell of the pump, the case can support the entire pump structure and protect the pump components from external damage. The pump case is the cornerstone of the pump’s ability to withstand the impact of high-speed fluids.

The sealed design of the casing can ensure that the liquid in the pump will not leak and play a certain sealing role.

The design of the casing is the fundamental reason for the flow direction of the liquid in the pump. The shape of the case determines how the liquid flows in the pump and can guide the fluid to the outlet position.

There are many materials for making pump casing. The selection of materials should be based on the nature of the medium to be transported, the working environment, pressure and other factors.

Commonly used materials include ductile iron, high chromium alloy, stainless steel and other composite materials.

• If you need to transport ordinary media, such as water or clean liquids, it is more economical to choose cast iron or stainless steel.
• For processing corrosive or high-temperature and high-pressure fluids, stainless steel and high-chromium alloy are more suitable.
• If the medium to be processed contains a large number of solid particles or sharp objects, high-chromium alloy with the highest abrasion resistance is the best choice.
• Composite materials are lightweight options. If your pump requires a small volume, then please choose composite materials, such as peristaltic pumps.

In any case, only by choosing the right material can the pump achieve the best efficiency and thus achieve a longer service life.

Advantages: Double Volute Casing adopts a double shell design, which can effectively reduce radial loads and reduce the bearing pressure of the pump shaft, making it more solid and stable, able to withstand the impact of higher pressure fluids, and having a longer service life.

Disadvantages: Casting is more difficult, and compared with single volute pump casing, the production cost is higher and the cost of use is high.

Application: Double volute casing is suitable for high pressure, large flow and more severe use environments. It can withstand the impact of high-speed fluids and can also transport slurry containing solid particles.

Advantages: Compared with other pump casings, Diffuser casing has a multi-stage pressurization function, which makes it more efficient and can provide higher pressure, good stability, and less maintenance.

Disadvantages: Diffuser casing has a complex structure, high manufacturing cost, and a limited range of use. Because there are a series of diffusers in the pump, the volume and weight are relatively large.

Application: Diffuser casing is mostly used in high-pressure multi-stage pumps to handle high-pressure fluids. It can also be used in the chemical, petroleum, and natural gas industries to output high-pressure fluids.

If you want to learn more, please visit our website Coal Preparation Plant Pump.